The Enemies Project: A “Proud Boy” and a Leftist walk into a TV studio…
This is quite a departure from my usual posts about my usual interrelated environmental and animals topics of forests, deforestation, the cow-slaughtering industries (so-called dairy & beef), the heating climate and what should be the rights of subjugated (aka, “domesticated’) animals to live free, unmolested — or to live at all.
I was invited to participate in an ongoing documentary series, “The Enemies Project,” which broadcasts on YouTube. The show is the brainchild and labor of love of producer and moderator Larry Rosen, a professional mediator. In this ongoing new series of recorded, lengthy, in-depth conversations, he brings together pairs of people with opposite, even opposing beliefs about one specific issue, social and/or political issue.
The episode I participated in was about Totalitarianism or Dictatorship in the U.S. I spent over 3 hours in conversation with “Matt,” a self-identified member of The Proud Boys, what many people consider a Right-wing group. While I’m a self-identified Left-winger, a fan of Bernie Sanders (and Ralph Nader back in the day), and increasingly identify as anti-capitalist and pro-socialism (which is not communism, nor what Russia is or has ever been). But of course the vast majority of Americans don’t even know what socialism is — only that it’s bad, and anti-American. (Which demonstrates just how wildly uneducated the average American is.)
When watching this episode, please keep these thoughts in mind:
1) This show is just over 1 hour long — but edited from over 3 hrs. of discussion. And there will be a part 2, since this was filmed just before Trump won his second term. (He didn’t win the 2020 election of course. Duh.)
2) The entire point of The Enemies Project is NOT for one “side” to win an argument; in fact each episode demonstrates “winning an argument” is actually impossible, for a number of reasons.
Question: When was the last time when one side of the Trump debate convinced the other side? Has a Trumper convinced you that Trump was a God; or that you convinced a Trumper that Trump was a Monster? And yet most of us keep trying. Or, in some ways worse, assume and assert “all those people are idiots.”
So even if I was a more skilled polemicist with more facts on hand, the anger and frustration generated by both sides in arguing with someone makes their conversion to your viewpoint impossible, regardless of the “facts” — and the facts you/we/I base our point of view on won’t be agreed upon anyway!
3) One major purpose of The Enemies Project is to humanize the opposition. For my fellow liberals, e.g., to see that Matt is sincere. He’s also, perhaps surprisingly, driven by a similar love of country & the American democracy (actually a democratic republic). That only becomes apparent when we dig down below our surface disagreements (on seemingly everything).
4) Proud Boy Matt & I are consuming almost 100% different news sources/media. During this experience, I confirmed one assumption I had going into it, that the majority (not all) of right-wingers who attacked the Capitol believed that they were defending democracy — but were tragically misled by their Dear Leader. (And yes, that there is a cult-ish quasi-religious quality at work here too.)
Okay, enough preamble. Be prepared to be interested, probably annoyed and frustrated, but maybe get a bit more insight into the great political divide in this country which has frayed our social fabric (along with smartphones and social media and the internet).
Matt & I even agree on many of these reasons we’re in the predicament we’re in.



